We help you get the protection you need for your life and business.

Insurance | Benefits | Wealth Management | Tax

Peace of Mind

Life is full of uncertainty…but your (business or life) doesn’t have to be. Because of our comprehensive approach to Risk Management, you can focus on what really matters.

For something this important, trust the team that knows.

Whitaker Myers knowledgeable team


We understand and embrace that the procurement of insurance policies is only one part of risk management –
and implement a plan for
overall risk management AND regularly monitor that plan.

This comprehensive approach gives our clients 3 very important things:


We don’t just answer the questions you ask, we answer the questions you don’t even know to ask! We know this business inside and out.  Our agency was established in 1869.


If you’ve never had an insurance claim…chances are, you eventually will have one.  Our competitive advantage is that we not only represent some of the very best Insurers in the country, but also have our own claims department right here at the agency where we make it our business to offer our clients prompt, thorough customer service.

Peace of Mind

Life is full of uncertainty…but your (business or life) doesn’t have to be. Because of our comprehensive approach to Risk Management, you can focus on what really matters.

two individuals reviewing document
bungalow home

Helping you Manage Some of Life’s Most Vexing and Risk-laden Problems.

  • We help manage and lower the cost of risk for a wide range of concerns – from complex commercial needs to homeowner, investment, personal auto, retirement or health related solutions. 
  • The process can be complicated, we offer consolidated, comprehensive insurance and wealth management solutions. 
  • Whitaker Myers has been helping our community since 1869.

Use Us as Your Personal Guide.

We treat everyone as if they were a part of our family, so each person that steps foot into any of our offices leaves with the knowledge and understanding that they were seeking.

Get A Quote

Talking on the phone in an office setting

What Our Clients Say

Whenever we have an issue or claim, Whitaker Myers is always there to support us, be available, be accessible, and at times, if we need them to come down to the camp to grapple with something; they are on the spot. It’s great because they know our organization and understand what we are trying to do and how we are trying to serve society. They help us find the solution.

Trevor Dunlap, Executive Director of Nuhop

I appreciate the knowledge and help that John has provided me. He is really helping me with my finances.

Charles Ford

Our relationship with Whitaker Myers dates back at least 100 years. They make a concerted effort to understand our business and its associated risks. It’s easy for me to recommend Whitaker Myers to another manufacturing company. I know they will do their homework, work hard to find the right solution, and won’t cut corners.

Bill Fagert , President of The Wooster Brush Company
stock photo of family standing in front of car
older couple on beach

Our Services

  • Commercial
  • Home & Auto
  • Employee Benefits
  • Individual Health & Life
  • Medicare
  • Wealth Managment

Meet Scott Allen, Chairman/ CEO

Scott Allen

We are truly unique among insurance agencies and brokerages.

What makes Whitaker-Myers DIFFERENT is that we aren’t in the business of simply selling insurance policies. In fact, when people want to buy a policy, we usually aren’t looking to sell one. We prefer clients, not customers – and there is a difference. When we become a trusted advisor, someone you look to for answers and from whom you expect results, then you’ve become a “client.” That’s how we’d like to partner with you, and we’d be grateful for the opportunity to serve you.

Ready to Get Started?